Various methods for choosing who will participate in a deliberative body or activity


1) Election: People selected by the votes of those who will be effected, or by a geographical population. (They may be elected as representatives of their constituents' interests in legislative or bargaining activities, or as presenters of their constituents' viewpoints, but they are usually seen as answerable in some way to those who elected them.)


2) Random Selection: People chosen at random from a specific population.


3) Stake Holder selection: Representatives of interest groups concerned about the issue in question.


4) Demographic Selection: People who collectively represent the demographic or opinion profile of a larger population or community, according to certain parameters (e.g., gender, race, ethnicity, location, socio-economic status, or opinion on the issue in question).


5) Volunteer Selection: Anyone interested in the issue. (A low-level form of this is "whoever shows up," which usually includes an inordinate proportion of partisans.)


6) Cellular Selection: Several comparable groups of people chosen by comparable means, such as people chosen at random from different sizes of towns.


7) Community Reference Selection: People whose names come up repeatedly when the need for a particular kind of group is made known to networks linked to all sectors of the whole community.


8) Powerholder Selection: Those who have the power to implement or block any decisions are selected (or select who they want). This is often combined with stakeholder selection.


9) Expertise Selection: Those with the most knowledge, experience, competence or credentials regarding the issue under consideration.


10) Hybrid Selection Methods (Mixed): These combine various methods above, such as choosing a Demographic Selection from among a pool of volunteers (as in Consensus Conference), or making a demographic selection from a randomly selected pool (as in manya Citizen Jury). This latter method is sometimes called Stratified Sampling, which can also mean selecting people randomly from within several different specified demographic groups. Cellular Selection is always combined with one or more specific selection methods. In a Citizen Deliberative Council, representatives, stakeholders, powerholders and experts are viewed as resources for groups of citizens usually chosen by some mix of random, demographic, volunteer or community reference selection.


 

This is a living story of the Process Arts, including many particular Process. Anyone can browse; if you'd like to edit things, or add a process, you may request an account.

 

Processes

 

Users

 

All cards

all cards

 

  • You can open and close cards in place. Just click on ~1383/3259.png or the card name.
  • To get to the page (and web address) for a card, click on ~1709/3792.png.
  • When you're editing, to create links within the website (even to a card that doesn't yet exist), put double square brackets around some text, like this.

To learn more see the Wagn documentation.

 

If you have questions, contact the Process Arts wiki support team. We may also be online live, or you can just ask your question here and someone will answer it shortly:


see http://p2pfoundation.net/Category:Facilitation where we are also listing similar practices

  --Michel Bauwens (Not signed in).....Sun Jan 31 00:53:33 -0800 2010


The Bohm Dialogue, especially Collective Reflection has significance for me in terms of artistic critique and dialogue.

If one wanted to connect this to Jungian thought I'd relate to that.

  --Srule Brachman (Not signed in).....Mon May 21 17:09:16 +0000 2012

 

 

 

 

Wheeled by Wagn v. 0.15.6