The Citizen Initiative Review (CIR) is a political process through which an official Citizen Deliberative Council reviews proposed ballot initiatives and summarizes their findings and recommendations in voter information booklets. This allows informed citizen deliberation and the voice of "We the People" to compete with special interest advertising during ballot initiative campaigns.

In Washington state (USA):

• http://www.munileague.org/issues/2002/InitiativeReportfinal.htm
• http://www.cirwa.org/howitworks.php
• http://www.cirwa.org/initiative.php

Oregon:

• http://www.healthydemocracyoregon.org/
• Closing circle of participants in their 2008 trial: http://www.healthydemocracyoregon.org/node/94